masterkey logo
40 S Circle Dr
Score
0
Santa Cruz, CA

40 S Circle Dr

5.5M
4 bd • 6 ba • 6,683 sf

This analysis was generated on 2/20/2025. It is for entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as real estate or investment advice.

AI Property Analysis

0:00
0:00 / 0:00
List Price

$5,500,000

Price/Sq.Ft

$823

Year Built

2020

AI Property Analysis

A comprehensive evaluation of this property's features, market position, and investment potential.

The Good

• Prestigious Location: Situated in the sought-after Pasatiempo golf community, home to the world-class Pasatiempo Golf Course, this property offers exclusivity and prestige. • Modern Construction and High-End Finishes: Built in 2020 with attention to detail and top-of-the-line materials, this home offers modern amenities and a luxurious living experience. • Energy Efficiency: The energy-efficient solar home design helps reduce utility costs and environmental impact. • Ample Parking: The 6-car garage capacity is a significant asset, providing ample parking and storage space. • Potential for Multi-Generational Living: The unfinished basement area is designed for a ground-level accessory dwelling unit with a separate entrance, providing flexibility for extended family or rental income.

The Bad

• High Price per Square Foot: At $822.98 per square foot, this property is priced above the Santa Cruz County average. This high cost may deter some buyers, even within the luxury market. • Unfinished Basement: While the unfinished basement offers potential, it requires additional investment to complete the planned home theatre and accessory dwelling unit. Buyers seeking a move-in-ready home may find this a drawback. • High Estimated Insurance: The estimated annual insurance cost of $19,800 is significantly higher than average, adding to the overall cost of ownership. • Moderate Fire Risk: A fire risk score of 4/10 indicates a moderate risk, requiring homeowners to take precautions and potentially impacting insurance rates. • Air Quality Concerns: The severe air quality risk (7/10) and 13 bad air days per year may be a concern for some buyers, particularly those with respiratory sensitivities.

The Ugly

• Inflated Initial Listing Price and Subsequent Reduction: The property was initially listed at $5,900,000, a 1375% increase from its 2014 sale price of $400,000. The subsequent 6.8% price reduction to $5,500,000 after 175 days on the market suggests the initial price was significantly overvalued, potentially deterring buyers. • Extremely High Estimated Insurance Cost: The estimated annual insurance cost of $19,800 is exceptionally high, representing approximately 0.36% of the property's value. This could be due to a combination of factors, including the home's high value, location in a fire-prone area, and potential earthquake risks. This dramatically increases the total cost of ownership. • Air Quality Risk: The severe air quality risk (7/10) with 13 bad air days per year poses a significant health concern. This could necessitate the installation of high-end air filtration systems, adding to the cost and maintenance burden for potential buyers. • Crime Statistics: While violent and property crime rates are slightly below state and national averages, the total crime rate of 1411.5 per 100,000 residents indicates a need for enhanced security measures. The robbery rate is 39.2% higher than the national average, which is a significant safety concern. • Limited Rental Income Potential: Despite the option of a 4-bedroom rental, the estimated rental income of $5350 per month would not cover the high mortgage payments, property taxes, and insurance costs. This makes the property a less attractive investment for those seeking rental income.

Who is this property for?

These details are presented solely for entertainment purposes and are not meant to steer or limit any prospective buyer.

Best For

• Buyers Seeking Luxury and Exclusivity: The property's location within the gated Pasatiempo golf community, known for its prestige and world-class golf course, will appeal to those seeking an upscale lifestyle. • Homeowners Desiring Modern Amenities and Energy Efficiency: Built in 2020 with high-end finishes and solar power, this home offers modern conveniences and reduced energy costs. • Buyers Valuing Privacy and Views: The property boasts awe-inspiring bay and city light views in a tranquil, oak-studded environment. • Individuals Seeking Multi-Generational Living Options: The unfinished basement area is designed for a ground-level accessory dwelling unit with a separate entrance, providing flexibility for extended family or rental income. • Car Enthusiasts: The 6-car garage capacity is ideal for car collectors or families with multiple vehicles.

Not For

• Buyers on a Strict Budget: With a price of $5,500,000 and a price per square foot of $822.98, this property is positioned at the higher end of the market. High property taxes and insurance costs further increase the financial burden. • Individuals Seeking Minimalist Living: At 6,683 square feet, this home may be too large for those seeking a smaller, more manageable living space. • Commuters Prioritizing Easy Access to Urban Centers: While the Pasatiempo community offers tranquility, its location may require longer commutes to major employment centers or urban amenities. Traffic congestion in Santa Cruz can exacerbate this issue. • Buyers Requiring Fully Finished Spaces: The unfinished basement, while offering potential, requires additional investment to complete the planned home theatre and accessory dwelling unit. • Families with Young Children: While the schools are highly rated, the lack of immediate proximity to elementary schools (1.8 miles away) may be a drawback for families with young children.
Demographics
Area Median Income

$93,839

Property History

Price History
Ownership Timeline
$0Cash Purchase
May 25, 2022
Michael P DunnMichael P Dunn, Michael P Dunn Revocable Trust
Intrafamily Transfer
Non-Arm's Length Transactions
$0Financed
Dec 31, 2020
Julie A DunnMichael P Dunn
Intrafamily Transfer
Non-Arm's Length Transactions
$400,000Cash Purchase
Apr 15, 2014
Bruce L Dunn, Jean R DunnMichael P Dunn, Julie A Dunn
Grant Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)
$879,500Cash Purchase
Jul 31, 2000
Sattler Fred H & Lola TBruce L Dunn, Jean R Dunn
Grant Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)

Property Taxes

$30,956
2024 Tax Assessment
1.5%from previous year
Assessed Value$2,806,257
Tax Rate1.10%

Sunlight Analysis

Visualize how sunlight affects this property throughout the day and year.

Sunlight Analysis

Data provided by Shadowmap

Loading sunlight data...

Schools

Nearby school quality by education level

Elementary

6.5/10
Good

Middle

6.7/10
Good

High

7.5/10
Good

Financials

Monthly Costs
Market Rent (4 bed)

$2,590

Get a detailed estimate on Zillow
HOA Fee

$505

Unlock Premium Features

Supercharge Your Property Analysis

Get unlimited AI-powered insights and analysis to make confident decisions about any property you're interested in.

Best for serious buyers
  • Unlimited AI analysis
  • Unlimited AI chat
  • Advanced tools & insights
$24.92/mo
Billed yearlySave 17% ($60/year)
Cancel anytime • 30-day money-back guarantee

Location & Comparables

Subject Property
Comparable Sales
View on Zillow

Subject Property

Price
$5,500,000
Price/sqft
$823
Layout
4 bd6 ba
Days on market
174 daysat time of analysis

Stats in the Area

Based on 2 comparable properties nearby

Average Price

$527,500

942.7%

Your price is 942.7% above average

Median Price

$605,000

809.1%

Based on 2 recent sales

Price per Sq.Ft

N/A

No price per sq.ft data available

Comparable Properties

496 Glen Canyon Road, Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Price: $605,000
Sq.Ft: N/A
Beds/Baths: N/A/N/A
$/Sq.Ft: N/A
Sale Date: 1/27/2025
609 May Avenue, Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Price: $450,000
Sq.Ft: N/A
Beds/Baths: N/A/N/A
$/Sq.Ft: N/A
Sale Date: 1/10/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

Property Discussion

Start the Conversation

Share your insights on this property—did you visit the open house? Know of any hidden pros or cons? Your street-level knowledge could be exactly what another buyer needs.

You
Join 1,000+ buyers

Analyze Any Property for Free

Get instant insights and potential savings on any Zillow listing.

Free Analysis
AI-Powered Insights
Instant Results