masterkey logo
3005 Broadway St
Score
0
Indianapolis, IN

3005 Broadway St

265K
3 bd • 2 ba • 2,911 sf

This analysis was generated on 1/22/2025. It is for entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as real estate or investment advice.

List Price

$265,000

Price/Sq.Ft

$91

Year Built

1925

AI Property Analysis

A comprehensive evaluation of this property's features, market position, and investment potential.

The Good

The property at 3005 Broadway St, Indianapolis, IN 46205 offers several attractive features: 1. Location: Situated moments from downtown, with walkable access to Mari Evans Park and Fall Creek Trail, connecting to Monon and Fort Harrison Park. This prime location enhances its appeal and potential for appreciation. 2. Recent Updates: Significant improvements have been made, including a new roof (2018), new furnace (2018), new water heater (2018), new sewer line (2020), refinished hardwood floors (2019), and a new backyard fence (2021). These updates reduce immediate maintenance concerns and add value. 3. Price per Square Foot: At $91.03/sqft, it's priced significantly below the average for Indianapolis, which ranges from $150-$200/sqft for similar properties. 4. Size: With 2,911 sqft, it's spacious compared to many homes in the area, offering ample living space. 5. Lot Size: The 4,661 sqft lot with mature trees and a fully fenced backyard adds value and privacy. 6. Parking: Two private parking spaces are a valuable asset in an urban setting. 7. Historical Character: Built in 1925, it offers historical charm while being updated for modern living. 8. Potential Rental Income: Based on local data, a 3-bedroom home could potentially rent for around $1,400/month, suggesting a gross rental yield of about 6.3% annually. 9. Appreciation Potential: The property has shown significant appreciation, selling for $122,500 in 2018 and now listed at $265,000, a 116% increase in 7 years.

The Bad

1. Age-Related Concerns: Despite recent updates, the home's age (built in 1925) may lead to unexpected maintenance issues and higher ongoing costs. 2. Extended Time on Market: The property has been listed for 119 days with multiple price reductions, suggesting potential overpricing or hidden issues. 3. Bathroom Count: With only 1.5 bathrooms for a 3-bedroom home, it may be less appealing to some buyers, especially families. 4. Carpeting: Carpeted bedrooms may be less desirable than hardwood floors and could require replacement. 5. Energy Efficiency: Older homes often have lower energy efficiency, potentially leading to higher utility costs. 6. School Ratings: Nearby schools have relatively low ratings (2-4 out of 10), which may deter families with children. 7. Price History Volatility: The property has experienced significant price fluctuations, from as low as $5,000 in 2010 to the current asking price of $265,000, indicating potential market instability or neighborhood changes. 8. Median Income Mismatch: The area's median income of $56,563 may make the home unaffordable for many local buyers, potentially limiting the pool of interested parties.

The Ugly

1. Potential Hidden Issues: Given the home's age and history of low-price sales (e.g., $5,000 in 2010, $16,500 in 2015), there may be underlying structural or neighborhood issues not immediately apparent. 2. Possible Over-Improvement: The significant price increase from $122,500 in 2018 to the current $265,000 listing (116% in 7 years) far outpaces typical market appreciation, suggesting potential over-improvement or market speculation. 3. Market Resistance: Multiple price reductions (from $290,000 to $265,000) over 119 days on market indicate strong buyer resistance at higher price points. 4. Neighborhood Transition Risk: The extreme price volatility in the property's history suggests the neighborhood may have undergone significant changes, which could continue to affect property values unpredictably. 5. Potential Hazardous Materials: Given its age, the home may contain lead paint or asbestos, which could require costly remediation. 6. Zoning and Historical Restrictions: As an older home, there may be zoning restrictions or historical preservation requirements that limit future renovations or use. 7. Flood Risk: The proximity to Fall Creek Trail suggests potential flood risk, which could lead to higher insurance costs or future damage. 8. Foundation Issues: Older homes in areas with volatile price histories often have foundation problems, which can be extremely costly to repair. 9. Total Cost of Ownership: When factoring in potential repairs, updates, and higher utility costs due to age, the total cost of ownership could be significantly higher than the purchase price suggests.

Who is this property for?

These details are presented solely for entertainment purposes and are not meant to steer or limit any prospective buyer.

Best For

This property is best suited for: 1. Urban Professionals: Individuals or couples who value proximity to downtown and don't require top-rated schools. 2. Renovation Enthusiasts: Buyers who appreciate historical homes and are willing to invest in ongoing maintenance and potential upgrades. 3. Investors: Those looking for potential rental income, given the favorable price per square foot and rental market rates. 4. First-Time Homebuyers: The relatively low price point (compared to similar-sized homes) may appeal to those entering the market, if they're comfortable with an older home. 5. Empty Nesters: The space and character may appeal to older buyers downsizing from larger suburban homes but wanting to maintain some space. 6. Outdoor Enthusiasts: The proximity to parks and trails makes it ideal for those who enjoy outdoor activities. 7. Buyers with Household Income Around $80,000-$100,000: Based on a 28% front-end debt-to-income ratio, this price point would be manageable for this income range.

Not For

This property is not ideal for: 1. Families with School-Age Children: Given the low ratings of nearby schools (2-4 out of 10), families prioritizing education may find better options elsewhere. 2. Luxury Buyers: Those seeking modern amenities and finishes may find the property lacking, despite its updates. 3. Low-Maintenance Seekers: The age and potential ongoing maintenance requirements make it unsuitable for those wanting a turnkey, low-maintenance home. 4. Accessibility-Focused Buyers: The 1.5 story design may not be suitable for those with mobility issues or aging buyers planning for the long term. 5. Large Families: With only 1.5 bathrooms, the layout may not be ideal for larger families or those who frequently host guests. 6. Risk-Averse Buyers: Given the property's volatile price history and potential hidden issues, it's not suitable for those seeking a safe, predictable investment. 7. Buyers with Household Income Below $70,000: The purchase price and potential additional costs may stretch the budget for lower-income households.
Demographics
Area Median Income

$56,563

Property History

Price History
Ownership Timeline
$122,500Financed
Dec 21, 2018
Six Tail Holdings LlcAndrew Tullis
Warranty Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)
$70,000Cash Purchase
Feb 21, 2018
Paul Warner, Denis O BrienSix Tail Holdings Llc
Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)
$0Cash Purchase
Jan 29, 2016
D & P Indy Properties LlcPaul Warner, Denis O Brien
Quit Claim Deed
Non-Arm's Length Transactions
$16,500Cash Purchase
Feb 11, 2015
Krg Plus LlcD & P Indy Property Llc
Warranty Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)
$0Cash Purchase
Oct 6, 2014
Hendricks Portfolio Group LlcBrian Lee
Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)
$23,000Cash Purchase
Jun 10, 2011
Sma Investment Group LlcHendricks Portfolio Group Llc
Warranty Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)
$0Cash Purchase
Apr 21, 2010
Apex Capital LtdSma Investment Group Llc
Quit Claim Deed
Non-Arm's Length Transactions
$5,000Cash Purchase
Mar 17, 2010
A&L Urban Management Llc, Clarence LylesApex Capital Ltd
Sheriffs Deed
Foreclosure
$0Financed
May 22, 2007
Greenpoint Mortgage Funding IncA & L Urban Management Llc
Special Warranty Deed
Non-Residential Arm's Length Transactions
$0Cash Purchase
Oct 3, 2006
Dewan L Simon, Greenpoint Mortgage Funding IncGreenpoint Mortgage Funding Inc
Sheriffs Deed
Foreclosure

Property Taxes

$2,799
2023 Tax Assessment
25.7%from previous year
Assessed Value$242,700
Tax Rate1.15%

Sunlight Analysis

Visualize how sunlight affects this property throughout the day and year.

Sunlight Analysis

Data provided by Shadowmap

Loading sunlight data...

Schools

Details about nearby schools in this area

Financials

Monthly Costs
Market Rent (3 bed)

$771

Get a detailed estimate on Zillow
Unlock Premium Features

Supercharge Your Property Analysis

Get unlimited AI-powered insights and analysis to make confident decisions about any property you're interested in.

Best for serious buyers
  • Unlimited AI analysis
  • Unlimited AI chat
  • Advanced tools & insights
$24.92/mo
Billed yearlySave 17% ($60/year)
Cancel anytime • 30-day money-back guarantee

Location & Comparables

Subject Property
Comparable Sales
View on Zillow

Subject Property

Price
$265,000
Price/sqft
$91
Layout
3 bd2 ba
Days on market
119 daysat time of analysis

Stats in the Area

Based on 6 comparable properties nearby

Average Price

$270,275

2.0%

Your price is 2.0% below average

Median Price

$350,750

24.4%

Based on 6 recent sales

Price per Sq.Ft

$135

32.6%

Your price is 32.6% below average $/sqft

Comparable Properties

3605 Central Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Price: $375,000
Sq.Ft: 3,332
Beds/Baths: 3/3
$/Sq.Ft:
$11323.6%
Sale Date: 10/10/2024
3728 Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Price: $444,000
Sq.Ft: 3,102
Beds/Baths: 3/3
$/Sq.Ft:
$14357.2%
Sale Date: 8/13/2024
3162 N Capitol Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Price: $350,750
Sq.Ft: 2,361
Beds/Baths: 3/3
$/Sq.Ft:
$14963.2%
Sale Date: 9/5/2024
3735 Orchard Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46218
Price: $127,000
Sq.Ft: N/A
Beds/Baths: N/A/N/A
$/Sq.Ft: N/A
Sale Date: 12/4/2024
3244 Ruckle Street, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Price: $184,900
Sq.Ft: N/A
Beds/Baths: N/A/N/A
$/Sq.Ft: N/A
Sale Date: 11/22/2024
3547 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Price: $140,000
Sq.Ft: N/A
Beds/Baths: N/A/N/A
$/Sq.Ft: N/A
Sale Date: 11/8/2024

Frequently Asked Questions

Property Discussion

Start the Conversation

Share your insights on this property—did you visit the open house? Know of any hidden pros or cons? Your street-level knowledge could be exactly what another buyer needs.

You
Join 1,000+ buyers

Analyze Any Property for Free

Get instant insights and potential savings on any Zillow listing.

Free Analysis
AI-Powered Insights
Instant Results