masterkey logo

Buy a House Without a Realtor: Save $10,000+

March 9, 2025By Willow at Masterkey
Buy a House Without a Realtor: Save $10,000+

Purchasing a home without a realtor, known as "For Sale By Owner" (FSBO), accounted for 10% of U.S. home sales in 2023, up from 7% in 2020 (National Association of Realtors). With the median home price at 420,800(Q12024,FederalReserve),skippingthetraditional2.5–3420,800(Q12024,FederalReserve),skippingthetraditional2.5–310,520–$12,624. However, FSBO sales typically sell for 15–20% less than agent-assisted listings (Collateral Analytics, 2023). This guide combines market data, legal insights, and technology tools to help you navigate the FSBO process successfully.

Pros and Cons of Buying Without a Realtor

Advantages

  1. Cost Savings:

    • Avoid paying buyer agent commissions (2.5–3% of sale price).

    • On a 400,000home,thisequals400,000home,thisequals10,000–$12,000 in savings.

  2. Direct Negotiation:

    • 68% of FSBO buyers cite better control over negotiations as a key benefit (NAR, 2023).

  3. Faster Process:

    • FSBO transactions close 7–10 days faster on average (Redfin, 2024).

Risks

  1. Pricing Errors:

    • FSBO homes are 30% more likely to be overpriced, leading to extended time on market (Zillow, 2023).

  2. Legal Gaps:

    • 41% of FSBO buyers face contract or disclosure issues without agent guidance (American Bar Association).

  3. Limited Access:

    • 82% of MLS listings require agent representation for viewing (CRMLS, 2024).

Step-by-Step Process to Buy a House Without a Realtor

1. Secure Financing

  • Pre-Approval Rates: 73% of sellers prioritize buyers with pre-approval letters (NAR).

  • Down Payment Options:

    • Conventional loans: 5–20% down.

    • FHA loans: 3.5% down (580+ credit score).

    • VA loans: 0% down for veterans.

  • Average Mortgage Rates (June 2024):

    • 30-year fixed: 6.8% (Freddie Mac).

2. Identify FSBO Listings

  • Top Platforms:

    • FSBO.com: 25,000+ active listings (2024 data).

    • Zillow FSBO filter: 18% of Zillow listings are non-agent.

    • Craigslist: 12% of FSBO sellers use it (Statista).

  • Direct Outreach:

    • 29% of FSBO buyers find homes via yard signs or word-of-mouth (NAR).

3. Conduct Market Analysis

  • AI Valuation Tools:

    • Zillow Zestimate (4.6% median error rate).

    • Redfin Estimate (5.1% error rate).

  • Comparative Market Analysis (CMA):

    • Use platforms like HouseCanary ($49/report) to analyze recent sales of similar homes.

Mortgages 10 first-time homebuye

4. Schedule Viewings

  • Virtual Tours:

    • 63% of FSBO sellers provide 3D walkthroughs (Matterport, 2023).

  • In-Person Inspections:

    • Check for structural issues, HVAC age, and plumbing leaks.

5. Negotiate the Price

  • FSBO Discount Potential:

    • 22% of FSBO sellers price homes 5–10% below market value to attract buyers (Forbes).

  • Leverage Inspection Reports:

    • A $400 inspection can justify a 3–5% price reduction (HomeAdvisor).

6. Hire a Real Estate Attorney

  • Cost: 800–800–2,500 (depending on state).

  • Key Tasks:

    • Review purchase agreements.

    • Ensure compliance with disclosure laws (e.g., lead paint, flood zones).

    • Manage title search and escrow.

  • States Requiring Attorneys:

    • CT, DE, GA, MA, NY, NC, SC, WV (American Land Title Association).

7. Submit an Offer

  • Required Documents:

    • Proof of funds/pre-approval letter.

    • Signed purchase agreement.

    • Earnest money deposit (1–3% of price).

  • Contingencies to Include:

    • Financing, appraisal, inspection.

8. Navigate Closing

  • Average Closing Costs: 2–5% of purchase price (8,400–8,400–21,000 on $420,000 home).

  • Key Steps:

    • Appraisal (300–300–600).

    • Title insurance (1,000–1,000–2,000).

    • Final walkthrough.

FSBO Success Rates: Key Data

  • Closing Rate: 55% of FSBO listings sell vs. 77% of agent-assisted homes (NAR, 2023).

  • Time on Market: FSBO homes take 72 days to sell vs. 55 days for agent-listed homes (Realtor.com).

  • Sale Price: FSBOs sell for 15–20% less, but sellers net 5–7% more after commission savings (Collateral Analytics).

  1. Incomplete Disclosures:

    • 33% of FSBO lawsuits involve undisclosed defects (LegalShield, 2024).

    • Solution: Use a seller’s disclosure template from Rocket Lawyer ($39).

  2. Contract Errors:

    • Missing contingencies or deadlines can void agreements.

    • Solution: Hire an attorney to draft or review contracts.

Case Study: A Successful FSBO Purchase

A Colorado buyer purchased a $375,000 home without a realtor in 2023:

  • Savings: Avoided $11,250 buyer agent fee.

  • Process:

    • Used Zillow’s FSBO filter and HouseCanary for pricing.

    • Hired a local attorney ($1,200) for paperwork.

    • Negotiated a 4% discount ($15,000) after inspection revealed roof issues.

  • Timeline: Closed in 34 days.

When to Reconsider Going FSBO

  1. Hot Markets: In competitive areas, agents secure 12% more off-market listings (NAR).

  2. Complex Transactions: Short sales, foreclosures, or multi-family homes often require agent expertise.

  3. Time Constraints: FSBO buyers spend 40+ hours researching vs. 10 hours with an agent (Bankrate).

The Bottom Line

Buying without a realtor can save $10,000+ but demands meticulous research, legal compliance, and negotiation skills. Leverage AI valuation tools, flat-fee MLS services, and real estate attorneys to fill expertise gaps. While 65% of FSBO buyers report satisfaction (NAR), success hinges on understanding local laws, market trends, and your own risk tolerance.